How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
The novation, subrogation, or substitution of a loan does not exhaust the right to deduction if the new loan is used to amortize the previous one. If the cancellation and the signing of the new contract are simultaneous, the annuities and expenses of both operations are deductible in the proportional part attributable to the original loan intended for the housing. The portion of the installments corresponding to an increase in the principal intended for purposes other than the acquisition of the housing is not deductible.
The DGT's position remains constant regarding the continuity of the right to deduction in the event of changes to the loan. The doctrine has specified that simultaneity in the cancellation and signing allows for the deduction of the expenses of the new operation as well. The exclusion of the portion of the installments linked to principal increases for other purposes is maintained.
Turning points
-
Establishes that novation or substitution does not exhaust the deduction and that simultaneity in the cancellation allows for the inclusion of cancellation and constitution expenses.
Analysis based on 13 of 14 rulings with a stated position. Updated 26 September 2026.