How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
For the taxable event of a donation to exist, the animus donandi must be present, i.e., the intention to make a gift. In the case of non-proportional dividend distributions, if there is no statutory provision and an excess is received with the intent to make a gift, this constitutes a capital increase subject to Inheritance and Gift Tax (ISD). In transfers between accounts, the managing office must determine the presence of this intent according to the circumstances.
The DGT's position remains constant in requiring the animus donandi to qualify an operation as a donation. Clarifications have been provided on specific cases, such as the forgiveness of debt between a company and a shareholder, which is qualified as income from movable capital, or the distribution of non-proportional dividends which, without statutory provision, are taxed as a gratuitous capital increase.
Turning points
-
Establishes the essential elements of a donation: impoverishment of the donor, enrichment of the donee, and the intent to make a gift.
-
Determines that the forgiveness of debt from a company to a shareholder is income from movable capital and not a donation due to the absence of animus donandi.
-
Specifies that the excess in a non-proportional dividend distribution without statutory provision constitutes a capital increase subject to Inheritance and Gift Tax (ISD).
Analysis based on 15 of 16 rulings with a stated position. Updated 26 September 2026.