How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
The exemption for vocational training requires compliance with a subjective requirement (a public or private law entity authorized to provide it) and an objective requirement (subjects included in the curricula of the educational system). The exemption applies regardless of whether the training is eminently practical or takes place in clinical facilities. If both requirements are not met, the 21% rate applies.
The DGT's position remains constant in requiring both subjective and objective requirements for the exemption. The distinction between vocational training and activities of a recreational or personal nature has been maintained, as observed in the criteria regarding pilot training. Current doctrine confirms that the practical nature of the teaching does not prevent the application of the exemption.
Turning points
-
Establishes that teaching to obtain commercial pilot licenses is exempt vocational training if it is intended for the exercise of professional activities.
-
Specifies the exclusion of the exemption for private pilot or sports aircraft licenses, as they are considered intended to satisfy personal needs.
-
Clarifies that the exemption is applicable regardless of whether the training is eminently practical or takes place in clinical facilities.
Analysis based on 82 of 85 rulings with a stated position. Updated 21 September 2026.