How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
The VAT exemption on financial operations applies to the execution of orders and services essential for fund management, such as the calculation of the net asset value. Financial advice, whether independent or linked to execution, is not exempt and must be taxed at the general rate. Custody services, portfolio administration, and securities management are considered management services subject to the tax, as they do not alter the legal or financial situation of the parties.
The DGT's position remains constant in the distinction between management services (taxable) and execution services (exempt). The nature of combined operations has been specified, clarifying that advice is an independent and non-exempt service, even if agreed upon alongside the execution of orders.
Turning points
-
Establishes that advice together with the execution of orders constitutes a single non-exempt operation, preventing artificial breakdown to apply the exemption.
-
Clarifies that investment advice is a service independent of execution and that, as it is not an operation relating to securities, it must incur the general rate.
Analysis based on 6 of 8 rulings with a stated position. Updated 1 October 2026.