How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
The Spanish depository entity that records the ownership of securities is obliged to report via Form 189, which exempts the holder from filing Form 720 for said assets. If the securities are registered in the client's name at a foreign entity, the holder must file Form 720 if the legal limits are exceeded. In cases of withholding exclusion for subjects with a permanent establishment, the depository entity must report via Form 198.
The DGT's position remains constant regarding the distinction between the depository entity's mediation function and its reporting responsibility. The doctrine confirms that the obligation to report via Form 720 depends on where the ownership registration is recorded and not on agreements between private parties. Consistency has been maintained regarding the use of specific forms (189, 198, or 720) depending on the nature of the custody and ownership.
Turning points
-
Reiterates that the voluntary filing of Form 189 to avoid Form 720 is not feasible, strictly linking the exemption to the registration of ownership by the branch.
-
Specifies that in withholding exclusion procedures for taxpayers with a permanent establishment, the information must be provided via Form 198 and not Form 193.
Analysis based on 9 of 10 rulings with a stated position. Updated 29 September 2026.