How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
The division of the common property does not alter the composition of the assets if the adjudication conforms to the ownership share of each co-owner. If assets are adjudicated at a value higher than said share, an alteration of assets occurs, generating a capital gain or loss for the other co-owner. This result is calculated by the difference between the acquisition and transfer values, regardless of whether there is cash compensation.
The DGT's position remains constant at the core of the criterion: adjudication by share is not an alteration of assets, but an excess in value is. Throughout the sequence, the administration has specified that the existence of cash compensation is irrelevant to the generation of the capital gain or loss.
Turning points
-
It is established that the capital gain or loss occurs regardless of whether or not there is cash compensation.
Analysis based on 33 of 33 rulings with a stated position. Updated 24 September 2026.