How the DGT's position has evolved
Current position
Membership fees are deductible only if made with the intent of liberality as irrevocable, pure, and simple donations, without present or future consideration. The entity must be a recognized foundation, a public utility association, or comply with Law 49/2002. The intent of liberality is determined through objective criteria, analyzing the rights that the bylaws grant to the member in exchange for the payment.
The DGT's position remains constant in requiring an intent of liberality based on objective criteria. Throughout the rulings, it has been specified that the absence of present or future consideration is essential to avoid the mischaracterization of the donation. The doctrine has progressively detailed examples of rights that invalidate the deduction, such as access to services or federative licenses.
Turning points
-
Establishes that the payment of federative licenses is not deductible as it lacks a voluntary nature and grants rights such as participating in competitions.
-
Clarifies that if the payment of the fee grants the right to receive specific services, such as support classes, there is no intent of liberality.
Analysis based on 23 of 23 rulings with a stated position. Updated 24 September 2026.