The Directorate General for Legal Certainty and Public Faith has upheld the appeal filed by the company 'Calzada Solar, SL' against the refusal of the III Mercantile Registrar of Seville to file the 2022 annual accounts. The rejection was based on an alleged incorrect completion of the beneficial ownership identification declaration (Art. 18 of the Commercial Code and Art. 6 of the Mercantile Registry Regulations). However, the decision was overturned on the grounds that the registrar failed to provide sufficient reasoning for the refusal, thereby preventing the company from defending its legal position.
For companies filing annual accounts, this ruling reinforces the requirement that Mercantile Registrars' decisions must clearly state the ratio decidendi to allow for rectification or defence (Art. 326 of the Mortgage Law). In this specific case, the company achieved the reversal of the refusal without needing to address the merits of the error in the beneficial ownership declaration. Directors must ensure that notification of registrar decisions is sufficiently clear to allow for the presentation of legal arguments.
The tax team reviews your specific situation.